What are the advantages and disadvantages of illustrated books?

02 Apr.,2024

 

Book with images at least as important as words

A picture book combines visual and verbal narratives in a book format, most often aimed at young children. With the narrative told primarily through text, they are distinct from comics, which do so primarily through sequential images.

The images in picture books can be produced in a range of media, such as oil paints, acrylics, watercolor, and pencil. Picture books often serve as educational resources, aiding with children's language development or understanding of the world.

Three of the earliest works in the format of modern picture books are Heinrich Hoffmann's Struwwelpeter from 1845, Benjamin Rabier's Tintin-Lutin from 1898 and Beatrix Potter's The Tale of Peter Rabbit from 1902. Some of the best-known picture books are Robert McCloskey's Make Way for Ducklings, Dr. Seuss's The Cat In The Hat, and Maurice Sendak's Where the Wild Things Are. The Caldecott Medal (established 1938) is awarded annually for the best American picture book. Since the mid-1960s, several children's literature awards have included a category for picture books.

Target audiences

[

edit

]

Picture books are aimed at young children. Many are written with vocabulary a child can understand but not necessarily read. For this reason, picture books tend to have two functions in the lives of children: they are first read to young children by adults, and then children read them themselves once they begin learning to read.

Categories

[

edit

]

A board book

The majority of picture books are constructed in the same way as books for older children and adults, but there are a number of special types.

  • Board books are picture books printed on sturdy cardboard—called paperboard—for young children who tend to be less careful with books. Paperboard is used for both the cover and the interior pages. The pages are specially folded and bound together.
  • Soft books, also aimed at very young children, are made of cloth or soft plastic.
  • Pop-up books employ paper engineering to make parts of the page pop up or stand up when pages are opened. The Wheels on the Bus, by Paul O. Zelinsky, is an example of a best-selling pop-up book.
  • Touch and feel books included textured surfaces in the pictures. Pat the Bunny, by Dorothy Kunhardt, is a popular touch and feel book.
  • Concept books teach children about specific themes such as the alphabet or shapes. A famous example is A is for Apple by Georgie Birkett.[1]
  • Easy reader books are for children who are beginning to learn how to read and include simple text and descriptive illustrations.[1]
  • Non-fiction children's books are used to teach children in a simple and accessible way.[1]
  • Wordless picture books tell a story only through images. They encourage creativity and can be appreciated by children who cannot yet read. A famous example of a wordless picture book is The Snowman by Raymond Briggs.[1]

Genre

[

edit

]

The genre of picture books is unique because of the complementary relationship between text and art.[2] Picture books have existed since 1658, when the first picture book specifically for children, Orbis Sensualium Pictus, was printed.[3] The genre continues to be popular today.[3] While some picture books are written and illustrated by the same person, others are collaborations between an author and an illustrator.[4] These collaborations give equal power to both and allow each to bring their own creativity to the book.[4] Children's book illustrations can drive the plot or bring the plot to life.[4] Editors of picture books often look carefully for an illustrator that matches the style of the text, while still adding their own artistic value to the book.[4] There must be mutual respect between an author and an illustrator in the creation of a successful picture book.[4]

Pedagogy

[

edit

]

Picture books can serve as important learning tools for young children.[5] They are often used both in the classroom and at home to help children develop language and creativity skills.[5] A psychology study showed that picture-less picture books have been shown to improve children's storytelling skills and boost their engagement in books.[6] Additionally, children's picture books can help children tackle philosophical questions and life concepts.[7] For example, Mac Barnett and Carson Ellis' picture book What is Love? serves not only as entertainment for children, but as an introduction to important life questions about love and empathy.[7] A study in Australia found that reading postmodern picture books led to better text analysis skills for students.[8] Picture books can also improve young children's descriptive vocabulary and reading and drawing behaviors at home.[9] The art element of picture books aids with creativity development and engagement with books.[9] Not only can picture books help children develop literacy and creative skills, but they can also help children develop logical thinking and mathematical skills.[10] Math-based stories can help children conceptualize mathematical concepts and develop language skills to discuss math.[10]

History

[

edit

]

Early illustrated books

[

edit

]

A reprint of the 1658 illustrated Orbis Pictus

The production of illustrated books dates back to the earliest days of bookbinding. Medieval illuminated manuscripts were commissioned by the rich, and drawn by religious scribes. Perhaps the most important tradition of medieval art in regard to the development of picture books is the Poor Man's Bible, which sought to make illustrations of important Biblical events so that they could be understood by the illiterate. These illustrations were generally found either on stained glass windows, or as illuminations in Paupers' Bibles.

Orbis Pictus from 1658 by John Amos Comenius was the earliest illustrated book specifically for children. It is something of a children's encyclopedia and is illustrated by woodcuts.[11] A Little Pretty Pocket-Book from 1744 by John Newbery was the earliest illustrated storybook marketed as pleasure reading in English.[12] In Japan, kibyoshi were picture books from the 18th century, and are seen as a precursor to manga.[13] Examples of 18th-century Japanese picture books include works such as Santō Kyōden's Shiji no yukikai (1798).[14][15]

The German children's books Struwwelpeter (literally "Shaggy-Peter") from 1845 by Heinrich Hoffmann, and Max and Moritz from 1865 by Wilhelm Busch, were among the earliest examples of modern picturebook design. Collections of Fairy tales from the early nineteenth century, like those by the Brothers Grimm or Hans Christian Andersen were sparsely illustrated, but beginning in the middle of the century, collections were published with images by illustrators like Gustave Doré, Fedor Flinzer, George Cruikshank,[16] Vilhelm Pedersen, Ivan Bilibin and John Bauer. Andrew Lang's twelve Fairy Books published between 1889 and 1910 were illustrated by among others Henry J. Ford and Lancelot Speed. Lewis Carroll's Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, illustrated by John Tenniel in 1866 was one of the first highly successful entertainment books for children.

Toy books were introduced in the latter half of the 19th century, small paper-bound books with art dominating the text. These had a larger proportion of pictures to words than earlier books, and many of their pictures were in color. The best of these were illustrated by the triumvirate of English illustrators Randolph Caldecott, Walter Crane, and Kate Greenaway whose association with colour printer and wood engraver Edmund Evans produced books of great quality.[17] In the late 19th and early 20th century a small number of American and British artists made their living illustrating children's books, like Rose O'Neill, Arthur Rackham, Cicely Mary Barker, Willy Pogany, Edmund Dulac, W. Heath Robinson, Howard Pyle, or Charles Robinson. Generally, these illustrated books had eight to twelve pages of illustrated pictures or plates accompanying a classic children's storybook.

Beatrix Potter's The Tale of Peter Rabbit was published in 1902 to immediate success. Peter Rabbit was Potter's first of many The Tale of..., including The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin, The Tale of Benjamin Bunny, The Tale of Tom Kitten, and The Tale of Jemima Puddle-Duck, to name but a few which were published in the years leading up to 1910. Swedish author Elsa Beskow wrote and illustrated some forty children's stories and picture books between 1897–1952. Lang's twelve Fairy Books published between 1889 and 1910 were illustrated by among others Henry J. Ford and Lancelot Speed.

In the US, illustrated stories for children appeared in magazines like Ladies Home Journal, Good Housekeeping, Cosmopolitan, and Woman's Home Companion, intended for mothers to read to their children. Some cheap periodicals appealing to the juvenile reader started to appear in the early twentieth century, often with uncredited illustrations.

Helen Bannerman's Little Black Sambo was published in 1899, and went through numerous printings and versions during the first decade of the twentieth century. It was part of a series of small-format books called The Dumpy Books for Children, published by British publisher Grant Richards between 1897 and 1904.

Early to mid-20th century

[

edit

]

In 1913, Cupples & Leon published a series of 15 All About books, emulating the form and size of the Beatrix Potter books, All About Peter Rabbit, All About the Three Bears, All About Mother Goose, and All About Little Red Hen. The latter, along with several others, was illustrated by Johnny Gruelle. Wanda Gág's Millions of Cats was published in 1928 and became the first picture book to receive a Newbery Medal runner-up award. Wanda Gág followed with The Funny Thing in 1929, Snippy and Snappy in 1931, and then The ABC Bunny in 1933, which garnered her a second Newbery runner-up award.

In 1931, Jean de Brunhoff's first Babar book, The Story of Babar was published in France, followed by The Travels of Babar then Babar the King. In 1930, Marjorie Flack authored and illustrated Angus and the Ducks, followed in 1931 by Angus and The Cats, then in 1932, Angus Lost. Flack authored another book in 1933, The Story About Ping, illustrated by Kurt Wiese. The Elson Basic Reader was published in 1930 and introduced the public to Dick and Jane. In 1930 The Little Engine That Could was published, illustrated by Lois Lenski. In 1954 it was illustrated anew by George and Doris Hauman. It spawned an entire line of books and related paraphernalia and coined the refrain "I think I can! I think I can!". In 1936, Munro Leaf's The Story of Ferdinand was published, illustrated by Robert Lawson. Ferdinand was the first picture book to cross over into pop culture. Walt Disney produced an animated feature film along with corresponding merchandising materials. In 1938 to Dorothy Lathrop was awarded the first Caldecott Medal for her illustrations in Animals of the Bible, written by Helen Dean Fish. Thomas Handforth won the second Caldecott Medal in 1939, for Mei Li, which he also wrote. Ludwig Bemelmans' Madeline was published in 1939 and was selected as a Caldecott Medal runner-up, today known as a Caldecott Honor book.

In 1942, Simon & Schuster began publishing the Little Golden Books, a series of inexpensive, well illustrated, high quality children's books. The eighth book in the series, The Poky Little Puppy, is the top selling children's book of all time.[18] Many of the books were bestsellers,[18] including The Poky Little Puppy, Tootle, Scuffy the Tugboat, and The Little Red Hen. Several illustrators for the Little Golden Books later became staples within the picture book industry. Corinne Malvern, Tibor Gergely, Gustaf Tenggren, Feodor Rojankovsky, Richard Scarry, Eloise Wilkin, and Garth Williams. In 1947 Goodnight Moon, written by Margaret Wise Brown and illustrated by Clement Hurd, was published. By 1955, such picture book classics as Make Way for Ducklings, The Little House, Curious George, and Eloise, had all been published. In 1955 the first book was published in the Miffy series by Dutch author and illustrator Dick Bruna.

In 1937, Dr. Seuss (Theodor Seuss Geisel), at the time a successful graphic artist and humorist, published his first book for children, And to Think That I Saw It on Mulberry Street. It was immediately successful, and Seuss followed up with The 500 Hats of Bartholomew Cubbins in 1938, followed by The King's Stilts in 1939, and Horton Hatches the Egg in 1940, all published by Random House. From 1947 to 1956 Seuss had twelve children's picture books published. Dr. Seuss created The Cat in the Hat in reaction to a Life magazine article by John Hersey in lamenting the unrealistic children in school primers books. Seuss rigidly limited himself to a small set of words from an elementary school vocabulary list, then crafted a story based upon two randomly selected words—cat and hat. Up until the mid-1950s, there was a degree of separation between illustrated educational books and illustrated picture books. That changed with The Cat in the Hat in 1957.

Because of the success of The Cat in The Hat an independent publishing company was formed, called Beginner Books. The second book in the series was nearly as popular, The Cat in the Hat Comes Back, published in 1958. Other books in the series were Sam and the Firefly (1958), Green Eggs and Ham (1960), Are You My Mother? (1960), Go, Dog. Go! (1961), Hop on Pop (1963), and Fox in Socks (1965). Creators in the Beginner Book series were Stan and Jan Berenstain, P. D. Eastman, Roy McKie, and Helen Palmer Geisel (Seuss's wife). The Beginner Books dominated the children's picture book market of the 1960s.

Between 1957 and 1960 Harper & Brothers published a series of sixteen "I Can Read" books. Little Bear was the first of the series. Written by Else Holmelund Minarik and illustrated by a then relatively unknown Maurice Sendak, the two collaborated on three other "I Can Read" books over the next three years. From 1958 to 1960, Syd Hoff wrote and illustrated four "I Can Read" books: Danny and the Dinosaur, Sammy the Seal, Julius, and Oliver.

Mid- to late 20th century

[

edit

]

In 1949 American writer and illustrator Richard Scarry began his career working on the Little Golden Books series. His Best Word Book Ever from 1963 has sold 4 million copies. In total Scarry wrote and illustrated more than 250 books, and more than 100 million of his books have been sold worldwide.[19] In 1963, Where the Wild Things Are by American writer and illustrator Maurice Sendak was published. It has been adapted into other media several times, including an animated short in 1973, a 1980 opera, and, in 2009, a live-action feature film adaptation directed by Spike Jonze. By 2008 it had sold over 19 million copies worldwide.[20] American illustrator and author Gyo Fujikawa created more than 50 books between 1963 and 1990. Her work has been translated into 17 languages and published in 22 countries. Her most popular books, Babies and Baby Animals, have sold over 1.7 million copies in the U.S.[21] Fujikawa is recognized for being the earliest mainstream illustrator of picture books to include children of many races in her work.[22][23][24]

Most of the Moomin books by Finnish author Tove Jansson were novels, but several Moomin picture books were also published between 1952 and 1980, like Who Will Comfort Toffle? (1960) and The Dangerous Journey (1977). The Barbapapa series of books by Annette Tison and Talus Taylor was published in France in the 1970s. They feature the shapeshifting pink blob Barbapapa and his numerous colorful children. The Mr. Men series of 40-some books by English author and illustrated Roger Hargreaves started in 1971. The Snowman by Raymond Briggs was published in Britain in 1978 and was entirely wordless. It was made into an Oscar nominated animated cartoon that has been shown every year since on British television.

Japanese author and illustrator Mitsumasa Anno has published a number of picture books, beginning in 1968 with Mysterious Pictures. In his "Journey" books a tiny character travels through depictions of the culture of various countries. Everyone Poops was first published in Japan in 1977, written and illustrated by the prolific children's author Tarō Gomi. It has been translated into several languages. Published in 1978, Roald Dahl's The Enormous Crocodile is in the style of a picture book in contrast to his other children's books. Australian author Margaret Wild has written more than 40 books since 1984 and won several awards. In 1987 the first book was published in the Where's Wally? (known as Where's Waldo? in the United States and Canada) series by the British illustrator Martin Handford. The books were translated into many languages and the franchise also spawned a TV series, a comic strip and a series of video games. Since 1989 over 20 books have been created in the Elmer the Patchwork Elephant series by the British author David McKee. They have been translated in 40 languages and adapted into a children's TV series.

Technology and children's books

[

edit

]

With the rapid technological changes, children have more options in the reading format. Print books are no longer the only choice; many are now available in digital versions. The usage of digital devices is increasing in the home and the school setting. Comparing digital and traditional printed books has become a popular topic. The University of California has conducted a study and revealed the differences in book format and how they impact children's learning.[25]

Children who participated in this study were randomly assigned to read the same book in different formats: eBook or Print book. Reading experiences and outcomes were then accessed. The study found that children are more visually sustained with eBooks but less likely to recall the story sequence. However, there were no differences in behavioural engagement. There is a slight difference in remembering the story. Children remember the story a lot more when a person reads it than on a tablet.[26] In conclusion of this study, children have equally attentive, vocal, and emotional engagement on both platforms. They remember more about the story sequence when reading a print book. Comparably, children talk about the device more when reading on a tablet, regardless of previous experience with digital reading.

This study shows some differences when children read on a different platforms. However, the format differences do not heavily impact children's reading experience when the contents are the same.

Picture book design

[

edit

]

Interactive design in print picture books

[

edit

]

There are many ways to design interactive elements in picture books; it could involve how children flip the pages, how the information is revealed, and the placement of sensory elements like touch and smell. The study conducted by Liying Wang from Tongji University analyzed preschool children on book interaction design.[27] It collects participants' emotional responses when interacting with six interactive elements: regular page flipping, open/close, rotates, touch and smell, pull/push, and puzzle. The study found that preschool children were quickly experiencing positive emotions when interacting with exciting forms. The most popular interaction forms are "touch & pull," "puzzle," and "pull/push." Moreover, there are no significant gender differences in the interest in interaction forms. Based on their findings, this study made the following recommendations for children's book interaction design: First the study recommended creating suitable interaction elements to stimulate children's positive emotions in reading. It will enhance engagement and positively affect the reading experience. Secondly, designers must pay attention to sensory experience in interactive design because it would mobilize reading initiative and increase concentration. Lastly, the interaction form should match the children's cognitive characteristics, in which the elements should help narrative and reasoning.

Interactive design in digital picture books

[

edit

]

With the popularity of digital devices, children have more access to digital reading. Many studies analyze the impacts of digital books compared to traditional books, and the finding turns positive and negative depending on the variables. One of the studies shows that digital books could benefit children's reading outcomes if the design of digital enhancement aligns with the story content.[28] However, if the digital enhancement is unrelated to the narrative, like games, it will negatively impact children's attention from reading, leading to poor comprehension.[29]

Recent research[when?] from the University of Stavanger presents many useful findings for designers regarding digital children's book design. Rather than weigh the advantages and disadvantages of digital children's books, it was focused on book design enhancements that could be optimized to increase children's learning.[30] The most significant finding from this research supports previous studies on book design enhancement. Children benefit in meaning-making when the enhancement is designed to align with the story, like providing background knowledge of the story event. In contrast, children will be distracted if the design enhancement does not support the storyline, as with the pop-up dictionary emended in the story.[31]

Awards

[

edit

]

In 1938, the American Library Association (ALA) began presenting the Caldecott Medal for the most distinguished American picture book published in the year, awarded to the book's illustrator.[32] The Caldecott Medal was established as a sister award to the ALA's Newbery Medal, which since 1922 has been awarded to the most distinguished American children's book published in the year. During the mid-forties to early fifties, Caldecott honorees included Marcia Brown, Barbara Cooney, Roger Duvoisin, Berta and Elmer Hader, Robert Lawson, Robert McCloskey, Dr. Seuss, Maurice Sendak, Ingri and Edgar Parin d'Aulaire, Leo Politi, Tasha Tudor, and Leonard Weisgard.

The Kate Greenaway Medal was established in the United Kingdom in 1955 in honour of the children's illustrator, Kate Greenaway. The medal is given annually to an outstanding work of illustration in children's literature (not necessarily in a picture book). It is awarded by Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals (CILIP). The Deutscher Jugendliteraturpreis (German Youth literature prize) has included a category for picture books since 1965. The IBBY Hans Christian Andersen Award for Illustration has been awarded since 1966. The Boston Globe-Horn Book Award, first presented in 1967, includes a category for picture books.

In 2006, the ALA started awarding the Geisel Award, named after Dr. Seuss, to the most distinguished beginning reader book. The award is presented to both the author and illustrator, in "literary and artistic achievements to engage children in reading." The Golden Pinwheel Young Illustrators Award was established in China in 2015. It includes an award for Chinese works and an international award.

References

[

edit

]

Sources

[

edit

]

When researching types of illustrations for children’s books, keep this in mind:

  • Which age group your children’s book is for
  • Types and styles of illustration suited for the age group or book style
  • How many illustrations you’ll have in your book and which type of illustrations (full page, half page etc.)

Let’s get right into answering your big question… What are the types of illustrations for children’s books and which one is right for your book?

All of the above points will help you answer that, and I’ll explain each one in more detail.

What makes a great children’s book illustration? The most successful children’s illustrations of all time differ widely, but also have similarities that make them great.

The illustrations for Where the Wild Things Are, Goodnight Moon, Dr Seuss books, I Wish You More, Tuesday and I Want My Hat Back are all different but still amazing in their own ways.

Understanding that can help you get great illustrations too. But more on that later.

To plan for your book illustrations, it’s a good idea to start with style.

Ideas for the style of your children’s book illustrations

The first thing is your idea of how the illustrations should look. Cartoony? Bold and bright? A bit scary? Whacky? Beautiful and delicate?

Your illustrations should complement your style of writing and the message of your children’s book. Sweet watercolour illustrations, for instance, can be a great match for a gentle, touching story. But they may not work well for a monster truck book!

Different styles could suit your story, though, so don’t feel limited. And most styles can be adapted to match the quality of your book. For instance, the same style of cartoon can be funny, goofy, cute, or even shocking, depending on a few slight variations.

It’s a great idea to study some of the best children’s book illustrations out there to get an idea of what you’d like for your book. There are many places you can do this, including your local library.

Tip: Study fairly recent books, as the children’s book industry has changed. Books from 30 years ago don’t match what is selling now. Study books published in the last 10-15 years.

Here are two pages where you can see some beautiful examples:

https://graphicmama.com/blog/children-book-illustrations-examples-for-inspiration/

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/01/books/review/best-illustrated-childrens-books-2019.html

Which age group is your book for?

Also keep in mind the age group that your book is for. And, just in case you don’t have a clear age group in mind, I have to mention it’s crucial. Children grow rapidly in their ability to understand and sense of humour, and what they enjoy changes. A book for a 1-year-old, 4-year-old, and a 10-year-old are all different.

Even though the story, word count and book types vary from age to age, most illustration styles can work for any age group.

Your options are many. The main things to keep in mind are if a kid in your age group will like and understand the drawings. Too abstract won’t work for toddlers. Too baby-ish may put off older kids.

The biggest tip here is: Look at other books for your age group to see what is selling.

What are the types of illustrations for children’s books?

You also need to decide what type of illustrations you want in your book. This will affect the overall look and feel of the book, but also how many illustrations you need. What I’m referring to here is the”size” of the illustrations.

There are four types of illustrations for children’s books:

  • Spot illustration
  • Half-page illustration
  • Single (full) page illustration
  • Spread illustration

So, what are they?

Spot illustrations

These are small, simple illustrations to liven up a page with text. They’re usually a quarter of a page or less with little or no background. Spot illustrations can be placed as a chapter heading, corner decoration, or next to or within a body of text. They are often black and white or done in a sketchy style.

Half-page illustrations

As the name says, this is an illustration that fills half a page. While it can be detailed, due to its smaller size, the background will be less detailed than a full page illustration.

Single (full) page illustrations 

This is an illustration that fills one whole page. Here we can pull out all the stops and include lots of detail, since it fills a whole page. You can also have the illustrator leave space for your text if needed.

Spread illustrations

Spread across two full pages, normally with text on the illustration. While a mix of different illustration sizes makes a beautiful book, going all out and making your whole book double-page spreads will make it amazing!

If you are doing a picture book and budget allows, go for spread illustrations for your whole book. If not, take as many spreads and single page illustrations as you can.

You can also make your book interesting by mixing up the different types of illustrations throughout. Your illustrator should be able to help you work out a layout that can work well.

How many illustrations should a children’s book have?

Another important point to consider is how many illustrations the book will have. This comes down to page count and which type of book it is. For instance, a picture book has way more illustrations than a middle grade novel.

Work out how many pages the book will be. 24 or 32 pages are common for picture books.

It’s important to understand, though, that in a 32 page book only about 28-30 pages are for the story. Sometimes even less, as some printers glue the first and last page onto the front and back covers.

Here’s an example of a common book layout to give you a better idea:

You’ll see you have 14 spreads and two single pages for the story and illustrations.

NOTE: The minimum page count for print with KDP is 24 pages. With many print platforms the page count will go up in increments of 4. In other words, if your book is 26 pages, they will add two blank pages at the end. Check this before printing.

Look at books for your age range to see how many words tend to go on a page and per picture.

Picture books normally have full page or spread illustrations on every spread.

Early readers can have somewhat less or smaller illustrations, but mostly they also have illustrations on each spread. These can be spread, full or half-page illustrations.

First chapter books vary from having illustrations on each page to only one illustration per chapter. They contain everything from spot through single page illustrations (and sometimes spread illustrations).

What should you not do when illustrating a children’s book?

There are some definite “don’ts” for children’s book illustrations. Knowing these can help you get the best illustrations for your book. Some things come down to taste or opinion, but other things are widely agreed upon. Those are the ones I’ll cover here.

Avoid this when getting illustrations for your children’s book:

  • Don’t compromise on having the best possible illustrations for your children’s book.
  • If you’re not an illustrator, don’t illustrate your own books.
  • Don’t hire an illustrator without a proven track record and great reviews/testimonials. At the very least, chat with them enough to REALLY get a feel of how they are. Make sure they’ll deliver good work, on time.
  • Don’t work with an illustrator who has no experience with children’s books. You get some wonderful illustrators, but if they have no book illustration experience, they won’t know the requirements. This can lead to wrong file sizes, format, and many other problems! So only work with them if you know all the exact requirements for your ebook and print and you’re willing to guide them closely.
  • Don’t use the same angle, distance (close-up, medium or wide view), poses etc. in all your illustrations. Make sure they are varied.
  • This is more about your writing, but make sure the illustrations don’t repeat the text. Avoid putting descriptions in the text (e.g. “red bike”, “blue shirt”, “black hair”), because the illustrations will show these things. They need not be in the text. So if it’s not critical to the story, leave it out. If it’s critical, make sure the illustrator knows to draw a red bike and not a green one.
  • Following from the last point, make sure the illustrations match the text. If you’ve read a lot of illustrated books, I’m sure you’ve seen examples where this is not the case. It’s annoying to read, “The kids were playing outside”, but the illustration shows them indoors.
  • Don’t try to show too much in the illustrations. They should add to the story, but if the illustrations need to show too much, it will become confusing, messy or be lost on the reader or child.
  • Don’t be too conceptual or abstract… especially for younger children. I can vouch for this as my almost 4-year-old has repeatedly asked me things like, “Why is there a red light around her?” Kids, especially young kids, don’t understand a lot of the concepts we’ve learnt as adults. Be aware of that.
  • Don’t micromanage your illustrator. They are a pro (or should be!) and can greatly enhance your book… if you let them! Don’t tell them in detail what to draw (unless a certain setting or action or specific objects, colors, races etc. are essential to the story or text).

The last don’t needs more explanation. Give the illustrator the manuscript (if it’s short) or brief art notes—and then let them do their thing! They may surprise you with how much better they make your book with their creativity.

What is an art note? It’s a very brief note saying what needs to be illustrated.

For instance:

  1. “Billy is walking in the forest.”
  2. “The girl and boy are swimming at the beach.”

In case you’re wondering how not to do it, here are the above two examples with too much direction:

  1. Billy, wearing a blue shirt and brown pants and sneakers, is walking in a pine forest with some rocks and bushes. We see him from the back, from the waist up. There is a path, but mostly dense trees.
  2. The girls and boy are swimming at the beach. She is wearing a red and white striped swimsuit. There are a few clouds, seagulls and a few people and umbrellas.

If it must be a pine forest because that’s important to the story, let the illustrator know. If it doesn’t matter, just leave it up to the illustrator.

Plus, if they do sketches first (which they should), you’ll have a chance to give feedback and ensure the illustrations turn out to your liking.

There are exceptions to this rule. For example, nonfiction needs accurate illustrations most of the time. You may need to give exact descriptions and even reference images. Or the book may be for your child or grandchild and you want the main character to resemble them. That’s okay! Send a photo, by all means.

The bottom line is, for all details that are unimportant, don’t stifle the illustrator’s creativity by insisting on them.

Children’s book illustration styles

Style is quite a broad term. It can refer to cartoon-style or realistic, whimsical, stylized, watercolor, charcoal, etc.

Or it can relate to an individual artist’s drawing or painting style, or “hand”. Of course, choose an illustrator with an individual style that appeals to you.

I won’t discuss individual’s styles here (since they’re as varied as there are illustrators in the world!) I’ll just go over general styles you could choose for your book illustrations.

Before we get into all the different styles, please also note that there are two major divisions in illustrations. These are traditional vs. digital.

  • Traditional illustrations, in brief, are paint,  pencil, charcoal, pen, any medium–on paper.
  • Digital illustrations are made on the computer.

Illustrators can combine these two, and they often do. Digital illustrations have become more and more common for children’s book illustrations.

One isn’t better than the other. Both have advantages and disadvantages, but in the end it comes down to a matter of taste (and budget—traditional art is often more expensive). It’s also good to note that digital has developed to a point where it can closely imitate all forms of traditional art.

Let’s go through the major styles of children’s book illustrations.

To keep things simple, I’ll divide style into two parts:

  1. The genre or drawing style of the illustrations
  2. The medium used to create the illustrations

It’s also important to understand I’ll be sharing one or a few examples of each, but in each case there are many more variations that will give you a different feel and look. I can’t share all the possibilities in one article, so I’ve chosen only a few. If you want to see more of a certain drawing style or medium, Google is your friend 🙂

#1 Genre or drawing style

For children’s books, drawing styles include the following:

  • Cartoon–cute or childlike
  • Cartoon–whacky or funny
  • Realistic
  • Whimsical
  • Line drawings
  • Sketchy drawings
  • Stylized

Looking at the examples below, you ‘ll see styles overlap. All the styles from number 4 to 7 are also either cartoon or realistic. Whimsical drawings can also be stylized, and so on.

Cartoon—cute or childlike

Cartoon style drawings have exaggerated features and are not true to life. The style can vary and some of the other drawing style categories listed above are subdivisions of “cartoon”. I divided cartoons into two main styles, the first being cute or childlike. This is the style you see for many children’s books, especially younger kids.

Examples:


Copyright: Marti Whiting-Pearson                  Copyright: Mo Willems                             Illustration Copyright: LeUyen Pham          
        


Copyright: Total Language Connections

Cartoon—whacky or funny

Because of the exaggeration in the drawings, cartoon lends itself perfectly to funny or whacky illustrations.

Examples:


Copyright: Dr. Seuss Enterprises      Illustration Copyright: Lee Wildish                   Copyright: Tedd Arnold
From Spaghetti with the Yeti

Realistic

Children’s books are almost never hyper-realistic. “Realistic” here refers to fairly true to life proportions, versus cartoon style that is not true to life. In children’s books realistic illustrations can be simplistic, or detailed.

Examples:

Illustration Copyright: MacMillan Education SA                   Illustrations Copyright:                Illustration Copyright: Erin E. Stead Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations                               Sal Murdocca                                From A Sick Day for Amos McGee

Whimsical

Whimsical illustrations are charming, childlike, carefree, dreamy, fun and colorful.

Examples:


Illustration Copyright: Valeria Docampo              Copyright: Emily Winfield Martin                                Illustration Copyright: Seng Soun                                                                                                                                                                                                Ratanavanh


Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations                    Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations

Line drawings

Line drawings are outline drawings that aren’t colored and have no gradation (no different colors or grey-scale). It’s (normally) drawn in one color and only uses lines.

These can also be used for coloring books.

Examples:


Copyright Evil Eye, LLC                                       Copyright Marti Whiting-Pearson                           Illustration copyright: Denise Brunkus                                                                                             Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations              From Junie B Jones and the Stupid Smelly                                                                                                                                                                             Bus
                                                                             

Sketchy drawings

Sketchy drawings are drawings that are unrefined and still look more like rough sketches than final illustrations. They can vary in their refinement and be rough, or hardly rough at all. Often they don’t have color. Sketchy drawings are often expressive, which can be a nice touch.

Examples:


Copyright: Amber Layne Nieves                                 Copyright Disney                          Illustration Copyright Quentin Blake
                                                                                            From Winnie the Pooh                From Matida at 30

Stylized

Stylized illustrations are not realistic and don’t have natural, conventional forms. They are often simplified, or made up of geometric shapes or patterns. They also often have flat colors.

Examples:


Illustration Copyright: Amélie Falière      Copyright: Jon Klassen                                 Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations

#2 Medium

Though they’re not the same thing, style and medium are often used interchangeably or overlap. This is understandable, since the medium influences the appearance.

For instance, watercolor is seen as a style. Though, in the stricter sense of the word, it is a medium. While it has a distinct quality, you can create different styles of illustrations with watercolor. Here are four watercolor birds to show what I mean:

The following media are used for children’s books:

  • Watercolor
  • Acrylic
  • Gouache
  • Pencil
  • Charcoal
  • Ink or pen
  • Wood cutting (not common anymore)
  • Metal etchings (not common anymore)
  • Lithography
  • Collage
  • Multimedia

Then, these last two are a slightly different category, but we can divide digital illustrations as follows:

  • Freehand digital illustrations
  • Stylized digital illustrations

Watercolor

Watercolor is a painting method with water-based paint. Use more watery paint, and you get more transparent, softer images. These illustrations are mostly whimsical, delicate, gentle or sentimental. Less watery paint makes for sharper, brighter images.

Beatrix Potter’s preferred medium was watercolor: http://www.artnet.com/artists/beatrix-potter/

On this page there are two more modern, beautiful examples of watercolor illustrations: The Three Questions and Blowin’ in the Wind.  

Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations

Acrylic

Acrylic paint is a fast-drying paint and can also be used watery or thicker than watercolor, making for more opaque colours and texture.

Goodnight Moon has acrylic illustrations: http://reviews-of-childrens-literature.pbworks.com/w/page/10581693/Goodnight%20Moon

Jennifer O’Connel’s preferred medium is also acrylic. http://www.jenniferoconnellart.com/portfolio

Gouache

Gouache is another type of paint and can again be mixed with water to change the consistency. It can be used dry, for what is called a dry brush effect that is textured. Here is an example by Ana Roque Sá:

It can be used at “normal” or medium consistency, as illustrator Mary Blair does, for a result like this:

https://www.wbur.org/artery/2016/02/15/mary-blair

Or it can be made watery and is then similar to watercolor, like this: https://www.artistsnetwork.com/art-subjects/animals/dina-brodsky-bird-paintings/

Here you can see a couple of interesting comparisons between gouache and watercolor: https://www.artistsnetwork.com/art-mediums/watercolor-wonder-watercolor-vs-gouache/

Pencil

There are graphite (greyscale) pencil drawings or color pencil drawings.

I Miss My Grandpa and The Gift Falls off by Jin Xiaojing are examples of color pencil drawings.

So is the work of Raymond Briggs, for instance The Snowman: Raymond Briggs Receives Lifetime Achievement Award – News

Adonna Khare is a great graphite pencil artist: https://www.artsy.net/artist/adonna-khare

Charcoal

Soonchild by Russell Hoban, illustrated by Alexis Deacon, is an example of charcoal illustrations. https://theaoi.com/2014/12/11/soonchild-book-review/

Olivia the Pig has mainly charcoal drawings, with splashes of red added in. You can see a couple of the illustrations here: https://www.scholastic.com/parents/books-and-reading/raise-a-reader-blog/olivia-book-high-energy-kids.html

Ink or Pen

Shel Silverstein’s books are famous examples of pen-and-ink illustrations: Shel’s Books

John Tenniel also illustrated Alice in Wonderland in pen and ink.

Wood Cutting

Wood cutting is a technique of cutting an image into wood and then using this to print.

Edmund Evans did the illustrations from The House that Jack Built by wood cutting.

There are more examples here: Book illustration: the woodcut

This method is uncommon today and would require a big budget for your illustrations. I’ve included it as artists mimic this style with drawing (not actual wood cutting). So if you like this style, you could get a similar look for your illustrations.

Illustrations from The House that Jack Built
Credit: https://digital.collections.slsa.sa.gov.au/nodes/view/2201

Metal Etchings

Metal etching was the most common form of creating book illustrations from the late 1500s to the early 1800s. It can achieve detail wood cutting cannot. There are different types of metal etching, but in brief it entails producing images on metal plates, which are then used for printing.

As with wood cutting, metal etchings are now uncommon and expensive, but illustrators can imitate it with ink or digitally. You can see traditional examples here:  https://universityofglasgowlibrary.wordpress.com/2012/08/28/book-illustration-engraving-and-etching/

A modern take may look like this:


Click to enlarge
Illustration by GetYourBookIllustrations

Lithography

Lithography is another printing process. A flat surface is treated with oil in areas to create an image. The oil repels ink and thus an image is created by the ink only sticking to the desired areas, which are then printed. Different colors can also be created in one image by doing multiple prints, one color at a time.

While not as common as most other media in this list, lithography is still in use.

The Terrible Troll-Bird is a good example of lithography.

Collage

Collage is made by attaching different materials such as cut or torn paper, photographs or fabric onto paper or a backing.

Eric Carle, author of the famous The Very Hungry Caterpillar, did all his book illustrations in collage. He painted tissue paper with acrylic for his collages. You can see examples here: Eric Carle | Carle Museum

Mixed media

This is a combination of different media. Mixed media is common in children’s book illustrations. Examples include watercolor and pencil; or ink, charcoal and any kind of paint combined.

Here are examples where children’s book illustrator Isabelle Arsenault used gouache, pencil and watercolor together.

Digital—Freehand

These illustrations are created digitally, in various kinds of software. Freehand digital art is drawn as one would draw on paper. Thus the shapes and lines are organic (not perfect geometry, exact straight lines etc.). There is also often shading.

There are sub-categories in this medium, but I’ll only mention freehand raster and freehand vector illustrations. Raster illustrations means the images are drawn in pixels (tiny dots on that make up the images on a computer screen). These drawings tend to have more natural shading, more organic and “imperfect” lines and look more like traditional art.

With vector illustrations the information is stored as mathematical statements. For our purposes, all that matters is the appearance. Vector illustrations often have more “perfect”, smooth lines and shapes (e.g. perfect circles), flatter colors and hard/crisp edges to the shading (instead of soft, blurry-edged shading).

As digital illustrations software has advanced, there are more and more ways to make raster resemble vector and vector like raster illustrations. But no need to get too technical in this article.

This is a broad category, and these illustrations can be extremely varied.

Here are a few examples from the GetYourBookIllustrations portfolio of freehand raster digital illustrations:

And here are a few examples from the GetYourBookIllustrations portfolio of freehand vector digital illustrations:

Digital–Stylized

As with traditional illustrations, stylized digital illustrations don’t have natural, conventional forms and are often simplified or made up of geometric shapes or patterns.

Here are a few examples from the GetYourBookIllustrations portfolio of stylized digital illustrations:

What types of illustrations for children’s books are there? Now you know!

There is more I could say on the subject, but this gives you a pretty comprehensive overview of the types of illustrations you can choose from.

In short, the best way to choose the illustration style for your book is by combining your personal preference with doing research on what fits for your age group and genre. And the best way to do that is to look at many children’s books!

Is there anything in particular about this subject you’d like to know more about? Then please let me know in the comments below so I can address your questions.

At GetYourBookIllustrations it is our mission to provide beautiful, affordable illustrations to help you bring your book to life! If you’d like to chat, book a call here.

Or if you’re ready to go ahead with your book, fill in our form to get started.

I’d love to read your comments!

  1. Which illustration style(s) do you think you would like for your book?
  2. Did I leave any important styles or media out?

FREE Webinar: How To Write A Picture Book Without Self-Doubt Or Procrastination, Even If You’ve Always Struggled To Turn Your Idea Into A Story.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to submit the form

What are the advantages and disadvantages of illustrated books?

Types of illustrations for children's books | Get Your Book

Are you interested in learning more about how to pop corn in a paper bag, pork crackling microwave, microwave popcorn packing machine? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!